Your 1 Plumber | Germantown Plumber | Maryland Plumber

How to Replace a Toilet

A plumbing company helping you replace your own toilet? What will we think of next?!

The “what will we think of next” part is kind of the point of this new feature of our company web site.

You see, it’s one thing to remind you that we’re always looking out for your best interests. Even better, we’re always looking for ways to demonstrate to put some real whallop behind that promise.

So from now, we’ll be featuring one do-it-yourself project per month on our web site. Many of them, of course, will have to do with plumbing…but we won’t stop there. Plus, each time we post new diy project instructions, the previous article will be archived.

So where do we begin? With the most popular and requested plumbing diy project of them all:

How to Replace Your Own Toilet!

Changing your toilet is an easy project that should take half a day or less.  The most common toilet has a separate tank that mounts on top of the bowl. These instructions apply most specifically to this type of toilet. If you have an integral tank/bowl toilet, a flush valve or a wall-mounted toilet, your procedure will vary somewhat.

Preparation for the Replacement

  • Before purchasing your new toilet, measure the distance from the rearmost bowl hold-down bolts to the finished wall behind the toilet. This is called the toilet’s rough-in. Most toilets are designed with a 12″ rough-in. Ask your retailer for help if your rough-in varies.

Check the toilet’s rough-in to be sure it’s the standard 12 inches from the rear hold-down bolts to the finished wall behind the toilet.

  • The first step is to turn off the toilet’s water supply. Then flush the toilet to empty its tank, holding the trip-lever down to let all the water run out. Sop out any remaining water in the tank and bowl with a sponge–make sure they’re both empty.

Removing the Old Toilet

  • Use a large, adjustable open-end wrench to unthread the coupling nut between the toilet tank and its water supply. You may need to hold the fill valve with pliers from inside the tank to keep it from turning.
  • Now you’re ready to remove the original tank. Most are held to the bowl by two long bolts. The nuts are located beneath the flange at the rear of the toilet bowl. Figure shows how to work with these.
  • With the bolts out, you can lift the tank clear of the bowl.
  • If your toilet tank mounts to the wall and feeds the bowl with a large, sweeping elbow, first remove the elbow. Use a trap wrench or water pump pliers for the slip jam nuts. Or, you can simply saw the elbow with a hacksaw.
  • Now you can remove the tank from the wall. As you unscrew the tank from the wall, support it so it doesn’t fall.
  • Next, take out the toilet bowl. Typically, the bowl is fastened to the floor with two hold-down bolts and nuts beneath trim caps. Some toilet bowls have four hold-downs.
  • Pry off each trim cap to expose the bolts and nuts.

You can pry off bowl-matching trim caps by lifting under one end with a putty knife or screwdriver.

  • Unscrew the nuts. If you have trouble, you can saw them off. A mini-hacksaw works best, or you can use a regular hacksaw. To protect the bowl’s finish from the saw teeth, use masking tape.
  • Now loosen the bowl/seat unit by rocking it to break its seal with the floor and toilet flange. Once loosened, you can lift the bowl and carry it out of the house. Be sure to hold the bowl level to avoid spilling any trap-sealing water. You may need help to lift the tank and bowl together. Lift it properly with your back straight and put the weight on your legs.
  • Stuff rags in the toilet flange opening to keep sewer gases out of the house and debris out of the soil pipe while you work.

Keep sewer gases out of the house and debris out of the piping by stuffing a rag into the toilet’s floor flange opening.

Preparing to Install the New Toilet

  • To get ready for the new toilet, first do a complete cleanup. Remove any old putty and wax from the floor and toilet flange. You can use a screwdriver or putty knife. Clean the floor thoroughly in case the new toilet’s footprint is different. Remove the old hold-down bolts–don’t reuse them. You may want to clean and paint the wall behind the toilet. If you’re going to replace the bathroom floor covering, this is an excellent opportunity.
  • At this point, install any new water supply plumbing you plan to add. A new fixture supply valve and flexible riser tube is easy to install and offers shutoff convenience later. The valve attaches to a short length of water supply pipe coming from the wall or floor. Have the riser tube handy but out of the way of the new tank.

Modern supply valves are compatible with flexible riser tubes for supplying the toilet’s flush water.

  • Also, inspect the toilet flange for sound condition. It should stick up about 1/2″ from the finished bathroom floor.
  • Temporarily set the toilet in position on the floor over the flange to check for levelness. Check it front-to-back and side-to-side. If necessary, shim under the bowl with non-rusting metal washers.
  • Install a new pair of toilet hold-down bolts. If there are holes or slots for the bolts in the toilet flange, they should be inserted in the openings. In a cast iron piping system, the hold-downs screw directly into the wood floor. Whatever the situation, your retailer should have them. Don’t try to use ordinary bolts. Install the bolts so they are the same distance from the rear wall.

Install the hold-down bolts with some putty to make them stand upright in the toilet flange.

Putting in the New Bowl

  • Toilet installation goes pretty much the reverse of removal. Handle the bowl and tank with care, since they can crack and chip easily.
  • Start by inverting the new bowl (or bowl/tank unit) onto a thick, protective padding of newspapers on the floor.
  • Seal the toilet to its soil pipe flange at the floor by placing a ready-made wax toilet ring gasket over the bowl’s outlet horn. The gasket should be room temperature, and the flat face should go against the bowl. If the gasket has a sleeve, it should face away from the bowl. Don’t try to reuse the old gasket–install a new one.

Fix a new wax toilet gasket over the bowl’s outlet horn, with the flat side against the bowl.

  • Two kinds of wax gaskets are available: those with plastic sleeves and those without.
  • The bowl-to-floor joint must be sealed around the edge of the bowl’s base, too. You can lay a bead of plumber’s putty so it will be squeezed between the toilet and floor. Or, use about 2 lbs. of plaster. Another choice is to caulk the joint with bathtub caulk/sealant. This is probably the easiest method. Ask your retailer to recommend a good caulk for this.
  • Remove the rag from the toilet flange opening. Now you’re ready to set the bowl.
  • Hold the bowl upright several inches off the floor so its outlet horn is directly above the toilet flange. Then lower it gently. The hold-down bolts should pass through their openings in the bowl base, and the wax gasket and toilet flange should meet.

Hold the toilet bowl in position directly above its floor flange, then lower it into place.

  • To set the bowl onto the floor as well as onto its gasket, rock it carefully from front to back and side to side while pushing down hard. You can rotate it a few degrees each way, too. This forces out the excess wax. As the bowl meets the floor, make sure it is level and square with the rear wall. Don’t raise the bowl from the floor while making adjustments, or you’ll have to go through the setting process all over again and replace the waxing.
  • Drop washers over the hold-down bolts and thread on the brass nuts. Tighten the nuts finger-tight only. Using a wrench at this point can break the bowl. Re-check both nuts for tightness after several days of use.

Hand-tighten the bowl’s hold-down nuts.

  • If the bowl has front-mounting holes, install two toilet studs with washers and nuts into the floor for the front two holes.

Installing the Tank

  • If the toilet tank hardware comes separately, install it. Remember that the trip lever nut probably has left-hand threads.
  • Now take the rubber spud washer, which fits between the tank and bowl, and set it squarely into the flush valve opening in the bottom of the tank. The washer goes beveled side out. If there is a rubber tank cushion, set that in place on the bowl. Then pick up the tank and lower it gently into place on the back of the bowl.
  • Install the two long brass tank-mounting bolts from inside the tank, sliding them down through the aligned holes. Place two rubber washers against the tank and bowl. Draw the washers and nuts up gently and evenly until they are snug. This finishes your bowl installation.

Finishing Up

  • Connect the tank’s water supply to the inlet valve on the bottom left-hand side of the tank (as you face it). You’ll probably have a coupling nut for doing this. The nut threads onto the inlet and works perfectly with a flat-ended riser tube. Don’t use any pipe dope on these threads.
  • Turn on the water and observe the toilet tank as it fills. If there are any leaks, further tightening should cure them. Check to see that the tank fills to the correct level, about 3/4″ below the top of the overflow tube.
  • Tighten the bowl hold-down bolts one turn (no more) beyond hand-tight. Cut off the ends, if necessary, and install the trim caps. You can fill their recesses with plumber’s putty (or bathtub caulk/sealant) and press them down over the bolts. Clean up any material that oozes out.
  • Then, smooth and clean up the excess sealant around the bowl’s base.
  • Now you can test-flush the toilet, checking for water leaks at the floor.
  • Install the new toilet seat and tank cover, and your installation is complete.

Need a Little Friendly Advice or Assistance?

If you have trouble with any part of this process, give us a call and if we’re not immediately available to assist you, one of our technicians will return your call at the very first opportunity.

Or, if the project proves to be more than you care to tackle yourself, here’s a $25 savings you can apply to our professional installation services!

New Toilet Installation Coupon